| Name | Weeks Picked |
| Ed Boyack | 15 |
| Andrew Brady | 15 |
| Olivia Brady | 0 |
| Nick Brady | 15 |
| Duski Brann | 15 |
| Jeff Cameron | 15 |
| Pat Campbell | 15 |
| Jason Cheney | 15 |
| Stephanie Clark | 0 |
| Michael Culligan | 14 |
| Beth Daly | 15 |
| Wes Dobbs | 15 |
| Chuck Drake | 15 |
| Becki Drum | 15 |
| Matt Drum | 15 |
| Zanne Ebersole | 15 |
| Eric Eggers | 15 |
| Tyler Epstein | 15 |
| Jenn Epstein | 0 |
| Tommy Galli | 15 |
| Danielle Galvin | 15 |
| Jason Genovese | 15 |
| Jamie Gillen | 15 |
| Natalie Gilmer | 15 |
| Jack Grady | 0 |
| Jen Grady | 15 |
| Randy Grady | 15 |
| Jeff Hall | 15 |
| Brian Hall | 15 |
| Michelle Harkness | 15 |
| Marti Harkness | 15 |
| Bill Hayes | 15 |
| Chris Heil | 15 |
| Steve Heil | 15 |
| John Hintz | 15 |
| Jeff Horn | 15 |
| Tim Howes | 15 |
| Dave Hubbard | 0 |
| Scott Ingram | 13 |
| Jordan Jackson | 0 |
| Derek Johnson | 15 |
| Nikki Kovacs | 15 |
| Tom Lang | 14 |
| Stacy Langrock | 15 |
| Adam Langrock | 15 |
| Greg McKitrick | 15 |
| Todd McMillan | 13 |
| Eric Milan | 15 |
| Jim Milbrandt | 15 |
| Carrie Millar | 15 |
| Matt Millar | 15 |
| Kristin Miller | 15 |
| Kelly Miller | 15 |
| Ryan Miller | 15 |
| Erin Murphy | 15 |
| Bill Nation | 15 |
| Beth Parente | 13 |
| Bill Perry | 0 |
| Justin Polk | 15 |
| Mindy Polk | 14 |
| Sara Prince | 14 |
| Lewis Ramsey | 15 |
| Eric Rangus | 15 |
| Jesse Reese | 14 |
| Jason Robotham | 15 |
| Chris Ross | 15 |
| Michele Sedam | 15 |
| Chad Sedam | 15 |
| Steve Sherrill | 15 |
| Noah Spitzer | 15 |
| Piet Swart | 15 |
| Phillip Taylor | 15 |
| Brian Taylor | 15 |
| TBD | 0 |
| Jason Trumbower | 15 |
| Ian Ward | 0 |
| Libby Watson | 15 |
| Martha Watson | 15 |
| Eric Watson | 15 |
| Jake Whitfield | 15 |
| Brian Willard | 15 |
| Sean Willett | 15 |
| Tess Wright | 15 |
| Collin Wright | 15 |
|
| Name | Weeks Picked |
| Ed Boyack | 16 |
| Andrew Brady | 16 |
| Olivia Brady | |
| Nick Brady | 16 |
| Duski Brann | 16 |
| Jeff Cameron | 16 |
| Pat Campbell | 16 |
| Jason Cheney | 16 |
| Stephanie Clark | |
| Michael Culligan | 16 |
| Beth Daly | 16 |
| Wes Dobbs | 16 |
| Chuck Drake | 16 |
| Becki Drum | 16 |
| Matt Drum | 16 |
| Zanne Ebersole | 16 |
| Eric Eggers | 16 |
| Tyler Epstein | 16 |
| Jenn Epstein | |
| Tommy Galli | 16 |
| Danielle Galvin | 16 |
| Jason Genovese | 16 |
| Jamie Gillen | 16 |
| Natalie Gilmer | 16 |
| Jack Grady | |
| Jen Grady | 16 |
| Randy Grady | 16 |
| Jeff Hall | 16 |
| Brian Hall | 16 |
| Michelle Harkness | 16 |
| Marti Harkness | 16 |
| Bill Hayes | 16 |
| Chris Heil | 16 |
| Steve Heil | 16 |
| John Hintz | 16 |
| Jeff Horn | 16 |
| Tim Howes | 16 |
| Dave Hubbard | |
| Scott Ingram | 16 |
| Jordan Jackson | |
| Derek Johnson | 16 |
| Nikki Kovacs | 16 |
| Tom Lang | 16 |
| Stacy Langrock | 16 |
| Adam Langrock | 16 |
| Greg McKitrick | 16 |
| Todd McMillan | 16 |
| Eric Milan | 16 |
| Jim Milbrandt | 16 |
| Carrie Millar | 16 |
| Matt Millar | 16 |
| Kristin Miller | 16 |
| Kelly Miller | 16 |
| Ryan Miller | 16 |
| Erin Murphy | 16 |
| Bill Nation | 16 |
| Beth Parente | 16 |
| Bill Perry | |
| Justin Polk | 16 |
| Mindy Polk | 16 |
| Sara Prince | 16 |
| Lewis Ramsey | 16 |
| Eric Rangus | 16 |
| Jesse Reese | 16 |
| Jason Robotham | 16 |
| Chris Ross | 16 |
| Michele Sedam | 16 |
| Chad Sedam | 16 |
| Steve Sherrill | 16 |
| Noah Spitzer | 16 |
| Piet Swart | 16 |
| Phillip Taylor | 16 |
| Brian Taylor | 16 |
| TBD | |
| Jason Trumbower | 16 |
| Ian Ward | |
| Libby Watson | 16 |
| Martha Watson | 16 |
| Eric Watson | 16 |
| Jake Whitfield | 16 |
| Brian Willard | 16 |
| Sean Willett | 16 |
| Tess Wright | 16 |
| Collin Wright | 16 |
|
